Picture this: You’re walking down a bustling New York City street, the aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air. You stop at a corner pizzeria, order a slice, fold it in half, and take that perfect first bite—crispy yet flexible crust, tangy tomato sauce, and just the right amount of gooey cheese. Now imagine experiencing that same authentic taste right here in Raleigh, NC. That’s exactly what Slice of NY Pizza delivers to Triangle residents craving a genuine New York pizza experience.
For years, Raleigh pizza enthusiasts have debated where to find the most authentic New York-style slice in the city. The search ends at Slice of NY Pizza, with two convenient locations serving the area. If you’re near Brier Creek Commons or Hillsborough Street, you’re never far from a taste of the Big Apple. Each location faithfully recreates the classic NY pizzeria experience, from the recipes down to the atmosphere.
What sets Slice of NY apart is their unwavering commitment to authenticity. They don’t just name themselves after New York—they bring the real deal to North Carolina, offering that distinctive thin-crust, hand-tossed pizza that has made New York slices famous worldwide. For transplants missing home or locals curious about what makes NY pizza special, Slice of NY provides the perfect introduction to this iconic culinary tradition.
The Authentic New York Pizza Experience
The hallmark of authentic New York-style pizza lies in its distinctive characteristics—a thin, hand-tossed crust that achieves the perfect balance between crispness and flexibility. At Slice of NY, each pizza is crafted with this tradition in mind, creating slices that can be folded appropriately lengthwise (the authentic New York way to eat pizza) without cracking. This folding technique is not just traditional. It’s practical, allowing you to enjoy your slice without toppings sliding off. The crust remains crispy on the bottom yet soft enough to fold, with a slightly charred edge that adds depth of flavor to every bite.
Slice of NY‘s menu centers around their signature Original NY Cheese Pizza, available in three sizes: small (12″), medium (14″), and large (18″). For those seeking something different, their Sicilian pizza offers a thicker, square-cut alternative for a generous 16″x16″ pie. They also cater to various dietary needs with a 10″ gluten-free personal pie. Pizza by the slice is always available for a quick lunch or snack, with additional toppings—perfect for trying different flavor combinations without committing to a whole pie.
Specialty Pizzas Worth Trying
When you’re ready to explore beyond the classic cheese slice, Slice of NY‘s specialty pizza menu offers creative combinations that maintain that authentic New York foundation. Their Stuffed Meat Pizza is a carnivore’s dream, layered with ham, pepperoni, sausage, and meatballs, then generously covered with extra cheese. For vegetable enthusiasts, the Stuffed Veggie Pizza combines spinach, green peppers, and mushrooms with additional cheese, creating a satisfying meat-free option. Both stuffed varieties are available in small, medium, and large sizes, making them ideal for sharing at family gatherings or office parties.
Among customer favorites, the NY White Pizza stands out with its blend of creamy ricotta, aromatic garlic, and melted mozzarella—no traditional tomato sauce here, yet still unmistakably New York in style. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza brings a spicy kick with chicken and hot sauce, balanced by mozzarella. Meanwhile, the Cheese Steak Pizza creatively combines two iconic foods—Philly cheese steak and NY pizza—with steak, mushrooms, and a blend of cheddar and mozzarella cheeses. Most specialty pizzas are priced according to size, offering excellent value considering the high-quality ingredients and generous toppings that distinguish Slice of NY from chain pizzerias.
Beyond Pizza: The Full Menu
While pizza may be the star, Slice of NY‘s menu extends far beyond their signature pies to showcase a wide selection of Italian-American classics. Their calzones feature a generous pocket of dough filled with ricotta cheese and your choice of fillings, all baked to golden perfection. The traditional NY strombolis offer another folded option, with varieties like the Original NY (ham, green peppers, and pepperoni) and the Cheese Steak (filled with steak, mushrooms, green peppers, and cheese). Each stromboli delivers a different flavor profile while maintaining that characteristic crispy yet tender dough that makes New York Italian food so craveable.
For those seeking a complete Italian meal, the entree section includes classic pasta dishes served with your choice of spaghetti, penne, or linguini. Options range from a simple pasta with sauce to more elaborate preparations, such as Chicken Parmigiana or Veal Parmigiana, all served with generous portions and authentic flavors. The sub sandwich selection rounds out the menu with both hot and cold options—standouts include the Italian Combo cold sub featuring ham, salami, pepperoni, and provolone, and the hot Philly Chicken & Cheese loaded with green peppers, mushrooms, and onions. These substantial sandwiches on 10″ rolls make for a satisfying alternative when you’re not in the mood for pizza.
Two Convenient Raleigh Locations
Slice of NY‘s Brier Creek Commons location, at 8301 Brier Creek Parkway, serves residents in northwest Raleigh and the nearby Durham area. Situated in the popular shopping center, it provides a convenient stop whether you’re running errands or making a trip specifically for authentic pizza. With ample parking and a central location near the intersection of Glenwood Avenue and TW Alexander Drive, this restaurant has become a neighborhood fixture. The Brier Creek location offers both dine-in seating for those wanting to enjoy their meal fresh from the oven and efficient takeout service for customers on the go.
The Hillsborough Street location at 2316 Hillsborough Street caters to NC State University students, faculty, and the surrounding neighborhoods. Its proximity to campus makes it a popular spot for study breaks, casual dates, or quick lunches between classes. This location embodies the authentic New York pizzeria vibe with its straightforward, no-frills atmosphere that puts the focus squarely on the quality of the food. Both locations maintain consistent quality and authentic recipes, ensuring that whichever Slice of NY you visit, you’re guaranteed the same genuine New York pizza experience that has built their reputation in the Raleigh area.
Special Deals and Promotions
Pizza night becomes more affordable thanks to Slice of NY‘s Monday night special, offering a large cheese pizza (a significant savings from its regular price). This weekly promotion has become a tradition for many Raleigh families looking to start their week with a delicious, budget-friendly meal. For those wanting to customize their Monday night special, additional toppings are available, allowing you to create your perfect pizza while still benefiting from the discounted base price. This consistent weekly special demonstrates Slice of NY‘s commitment to providing value alongside quality.
Beyond their Monday night offer, Slice of NY provides catering services designed to bring their authentic New York flavors to events of all sizes. Their catering menu features party-sized portions of their most popular items, making them ideal for office meetings, family gatherings, graduation parties, or any other celebration where high-quality food is essential. The restaurant proudly advertises their catering capabilities, emphasizing their ability to handle occasions of all types. Customers interested in catering services can view the complete catering menu online or speak with staff at either location to discuss customized options for their specific event needs.
In a city with plenty of pizza options, Slice of NY stands out by delivering an uncompromisingly authentic New York pizza experience to Raleigh residents. Their commitment to traditional techniques—from the thin, foldable crust to the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese—creates a product that satisfies both transplanted New Yorkers and locals. Beyond their excellent pizza, the extensive menu of Italian favorites ensures there’s something for everyone. At the same time, their two convenient locations make accessing this authentic cuisine easy, regardless of where you are in the city.
Suppose you’re craving a simple cheese slice for lunch, planning a family pizza night with their Monday special, or looking to cater an upcoming event. In that case, Slice of NY delivers quality and authenticity in every bite. You can contact their Brier Creek location at 919-405-1301 or stop by either location to experience their food firsthand. Their friendly staff and consistent quality have built a loyal following throughout Raleigh, turning first-time customers into regular patrons who return again and again for a taste of New York.
There’s something special about finding a restaurant that stays true to its roots while becoming part of the local community fabric. Slice of NY has achieved this balance, bringing a genuine piece of New York food culture to North Carolina without compromise. For pizza purists, curious newcomers, or anyone simply looking for a satisfying meal, Slice of NY provides an experience that’s worth seeking out—proving that you don’t need to travel to Manhattan to enjoy a proper New York slice.
Sources: slicenypizza.com, Slice of New York Pizza Google My Business Page
Header Image Source: Slice of New York Pizza Google My Business Page
